Employee vs Independent Contractor
A detailed comparison to help you choose the right option.
Employee
A worker who performs services under the direction and control of an employer, with the employer controlling how and when the work is done.
Advantages
- Employer controls work quality
- Eligible for benefits and protections
- Covered by employment laws
- More predictable availability
Disadvantages
- Higher cost (benefits, taxes, insurance)
- Less flexibility
- Harder to terminate
- More administrative burden
Independent Contractor
A self-employed individual who provides services to a client but controls how the work is performed, using their own tools and methods.
Advantages
- Lower cost (no benefits required)
- Greater flexibility
- Specialized expertise
- Easier to scale up/down
Disadvantages
- Less control over work methods
- Misclassification risk and penalties
- No exclusivity guarantee
- May have competing clients
Key Differences
- 1Control: Employers direct employees' work; contractors control their own methods
- 2Taxes: Employers withhold taxes for employees; contractors handle their own
- 3Benefits: Employees receive benefits; contractors do not
- 4Liability: Different insurance and liability implications for each
- 5Termination: Employees have more legal protections against termination
Which Should You Choose?
Hire an employee for ongoing, core business functions where you need control over how work is performed. Engage an independent contractor for specialized, project-based work where the worker brings their own expertise and methods. Be careful about misclassification — the IRS and state agencies actively enforce classification rules.
Related Templates
Ready to create your agreement?
Generate professional legal documents with AI assistance.
Get Started Free